Securing Data in Use

Homomorphic Encryption and Confidential Computing are two next-gen technologies, each crafted with the purpose of elevating the sanctity of data security during its most vulnerable state—when it is in use. While both serve as guardians of sensitive information, they dance to different tunes, orchestrating their protection through distinct methodologies and catering to unique facets of data security scenarios.

Homomorphic Encryption

Imagine a world where data, even while encrypted, remains fully functional—allowing computations to be performed on it without ever needing to expose its core. That's how Homomorphic encryption works. It is a type of encryption that allows computations to be performed on encrypted data without decrypting it. The result of these computations, when decrypted, matches the outcome of operations performed on the original plaintext data.

In homomorphic encryption, data is always encrypted end to end using a specific proprietary algorithm that supports certain mathematical operations (such as addition, multiplication) directly on the ciphertext. This means that a third party, such as a cloud service provider, can process data without ever seeing the actual data itself.

The advantages are:

• Data Privacy: Since data remains encrypted during processing, it is never exposed in its raw form, significantly reducing the risk of data breaches.

• Versatility: Supports various operations on encrypted data, depending on the type of homomorphic encryption used (e.g., fully homomorphic, partially homomorphic).

• Regulatory Compliance: Helps meet privacy requirements by ensuring sensitive data is never exposed during processing.

• Data Protection in Use: Secures data while it is being actively processed, which is typically the most vulnerable stage.

The disadvantages are:

• Performance Overhead: Homomorphic encryption is computationally intensive and can be slower than processing unencrypted data, although advances are being made to reduce this overhead.

• Complexity: Implementing homomorphic encryption can be complex and may require specialized knowledge and adaptation of algorithms.

• Non Standard: The use of proprietary algorithms
  

How is it useful?

• Secure Cloud Computing: Allows organizations to perform computations on encrypted data in the cloud without exposing sensitive information.

• Privacy-Preserving Analytics: Enables analysis on sensitive data, such as medical records or financial data, while keeping the information confidential.

• Secure Voting Systems: Allows votes to be encrypted and securely tallied without revealing individual choices.
  

Confidential Computing

In contrast to our friend Homomorphic Encryption, Confidential Computing builds an impregnable fortress around data during its active state. It is a technology that protects data in use by performing computations within a trusted execution environment (TEE), which is a secure, isolated environment within a processor. Confidential Computing secures data specifically during its use by isolating it within a secure hardware environment (TEE), but does not inherently encrypt data during computation.

Confidential computing relies on hardware-based security features provided by modern processors. A TEE ensures that data and code are protected while being processed, preventing unauthorized access even by the operating system, hypervisor, or other privileged code.

The advantages of this type of encryption are:

• Data Protection in Use: Confidential computing secures data while it is being actively processed, which is typically the most vulnerable stage. This enables adherence to emerging governance initiatives mandating data in use security.

• Performance: Since the TEE runs on dedicated hardware, it often provides better performance compared to purely software-based security measures like homomorphic encryption.

• Broad Applicability: Can be used for a wide range of applications without needing to modify existing algorithms significantly.

The disadvantages are:

• Hardware Dependency: Requires specific hardware support, which may not be available in all environments.

• Limited Scope: Protects data only while it is being processed; data at rest and in transit must be secured using other methods.

• Control over infrastructure: Requires overall architecture control over network and application layers to enable seamless transition from data at rest and in transit encryption schemes.
  

How is it useful?

• Secure Enclaves for Cloud Computing: Allows sensitive applications to run securely in the cloud, protecting them from malicious insiders and other threats.

• Data Sovereignty and Privacy: Ensures that data remains protected even when processed in different jurisdictions or by external parties.
  

Conclusion

While both homomorphic encryption and confidential computing aim to enhance data security, they do so in different ways and are suited to different scenarios. Homomorphic encryption provides a robust solution for protecting data throughout its entire lifecycle, particularly in environments where data privacy is paramount. Confidential computing, on the other hand, offers strong protection for data during processing, leveraging hardware-based security to create isolated environments. Depending on the specific needs and constraints of an enterprise, either or both of these technologies can be employed to ensure that data remains secure, no matter where or how it is used.

Interested in knowing more about how we can help, book a meeting.